Peer review free essay sample

Considering the most integral part of one’s paper, the data and information provided has to be well founded. That is why the research portion is the most important part. Anyone, can form an opinion, in which in the individual’s point of view might drown out the factual evidence. Secondly, what good is legitimate factual information, if it is interpreted badly. Therefore, one must have an open mind, and see all sides of the topic before making irrational statements. The editor differs from the peer reviewer in the sense that the editor basically has the final call. The editor has the final call on what is submitted for publication. The peer review provides the early insights to the author for correct data and strength of argument. In all honesty, I can not validate if the article has been peer reviewed. I can clearly determine the publisher, so if the article went through the right processes, then one can assume that it has been reviewed. Makes the argument that abortion is not safe and not the only option This essay identifies why abortion should be illegal. It presents evidence to support the health risks and how it can be seen as murder. Makes the argument that abortion is not safe and not the only option Evaluate the Essay After a second, closer reading of the draft, evaluate the essay using the Persuasive Essay: Final Draft rubric. Determine the level of achievement appropriate for each assignment criteria. (Level of achievement ranges from Unsatisfactory to Excellent and are found at the top of the rubric. Assignment criteria are found in the left column of the rubric. ) Identifies and Summarizes Topic * What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence do you have for this score? Kelsey identifies that abortion should stay illegal and should not be legalized making the argument of how it is killing a life, women are endangered, and less mental anguish to women. Identifies and Reflects upon Assumptions * What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence from the paper do you have for this score? Kelsey stated the facts while proving why abortion is wrong and not being too emotional about why it should not be legalized Personal Perspective and Position * What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence from the paper do you have for this score? She is saying why it should be illegal. She is pointing out that it is unsafe, expensive, and other options available. Paper includes limited fallacious reasoning. Position appeals mostly to reason. Thesis Development and Purpose * What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence from the paper do you have for this score? * She makes a clear statement that she disagrees with abortion and why it should be illegal. Guiding the reader where she is going in the body of her essay, what she knows to be right and wrong. What to say, based on facts and strongly opposing her position against abortion. Paragraph Development and Transitions What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence from the paper do you have for this score? Writer did an excellent job taking her stance in supporting to have abortions illegal. Writer stated her main points killing a life, women are endangered, mental anguish. She informed, explained and persuaded her point. Mechanics of Writing * What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion? Excellent * What evidence from the paper do you have for this score? Writer is clearly in command of standard, written, academic English. Three positive things about this paper are: 1) facts 2) key points 3) personal feelings were kept minimum Three things that could be improved are: 1) punctuality 2) persuasion statement 3) explaining statements Grading Criteria The assignment will be graded according to the following criteria: 1) First draft of paper posted to the Peer Review form in a timely fashion. 2) Each section of Peer Review Worksheet is completed. 3) Feedback provided to peer is positive and useful. 4) Directions followed for providing completed Peer Review to the appropriate peer.